I’ve been waiting to see Henry Selick‘s adaptation of James and the Giant Peach for almost 15-years now. And I would be lying to you if I told you that I wasn’t disappointed. Unlike most who saw it in theatres back in 1996, I wasn’t expecting a repeat of his very successful Nightmare Before Christmas – another Selick outing produced by (and in that case, conceived and designed by) Tim Burton. To his credit here, it’s Selick’s fully animated scenes that are the highlight of the picture. Some of the stop-motion work is truly inspiring – a showdown with a giant mechanical shark and underwater battle with pirate-skeletons come immediately to mind. But the film, sadly, falls apart in its clunky, live-action opening and closing scenes.
The first act of this adaptation of the famous Roald Dahl novel feels off kilter, as a live-action James loses his parents and moves in with his abusive aunties who make him work day and night, with only left over fish heads to eat. It isn’t until a magical giant peach grows in their yard that the film comes to life. James and his world become stop-motion animated as he meets a group of insects who join him on a journey over the wild seas to New York City in their giant-peach mobile, flown through the air by a flock of captured seagulls. Sadly, after all the wonderfully rendered scenes of high adventure, it ends as it began, with real-life actors on real-life sets and some really stiff, uncomfortable-looking performances. Perhaps Selick just isn’t comfortable directing actors. He should stick to animation.
Clearly, the animation is the highlight of James and the Giant Peach. That’s why this Blu-ray disc presentation will be such a disappointment to most who’ll pick it up. It appears quite soft and aged, like a film from a much earlier decade, rich with grain and a seemingly colour-shifted palette. Disney has cleaned the film up and granted it a great transfer for this new Blu-ray. I’m certain that most of the gauzy haze that seems to overpower some scenes here (notably the live-action ones) is intentional and part of the style of the picture. The image may not appear clean and modern here but the dynamic DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 soundtrack goes a long way toward making the film feel fresh. This is a powerful, explosive mix that is sure to please.
I enjoyed the film well enough and was pleased with the vintage look of the Blu-ray image but the big let-down of this new James and the Giant Peach disc release is the lack of engaging bonus features. There’s a brand new, Blu-ray exclusive “Spike the Aunts” interactive game that’s probably all right for the little ones in the family. Leaving me only the 5-minute long, EPK style featurette, a Randy Newman music video (blech!), a still frame gallery, and the film’s original theatrical trailer to enjoy.
I’m out of town for the week, on vacation and visiting my folks in the country where internet access is as rare a thing as social interaction. As I’m a day late getting you this Top 5 New Release list and my time online is sadly quite brief, let’s just bust into it. It’s an exciting week on Blu, with a lot of kick-ass catalogue titles being released alongside Kick-Ass the movie…Sorry. Bad pun.
Roman Polanski‘s The Ghost Writer is one of the best films I’ve seen all year. It might not be the most high-profile Blu-ray release of the week, but as far as I’m concerned, it’s the best thing going. It’s a great script by Robert Harris (adapting his novel of the same name) with some incredible performances by some of my favourite actors (I’ll watch pretty much anything starring Ewan McGregor.) Highly Recommended.
From the Blu-ray:
Special Features:
2. KICK-ASS
I enjoyed Kick-Ass well enough when I saw it in the theatre but thought it well beneath the hype that was surrounding it. I could happily go without seeing the film again but I’m curious to see how the image turned out in the Blu-ray disc transfer seeing as how the visuals were notoriously drenched in DNR from the get-go – a stylistic choice by DOP Ben Davis and director Matthew Vaughn. Kick-Ass grabs the number two position this week by heat-factor alone. It’s the disc that most people want to get their hands on right now (it’s still the #1 Blu-ray on Amazon as I type this!)
Escape from New York on Blu-ray. ‘Nuff said. If you’re not down with classic John Carpenter and classic Kurt Russell I’m not sure there’s any hope for you. This is one of their finest collaborations ever – the first and best outing of the tough-as-nails, gruff Snake Plissken character. I pray that this new Blu-ray edition lives up to the quality of the film itself but I fear the original elements might not have given MGM much to work with.
Henry Selick hasn’t really been grinding out a million films since his big breakout animated extravaganza The Nightmare Before Christmas. But the few movies he has managed to produce in that time are true gems. James and Giant Peach might not be a picture perfect Blu-ray disc but it’s a welcome addition to my animation collection. Full review coming this week.
5. A PROPHET
Combine the HBO prison drama OZ with a touch of the Godfather and you’ve got a glimpse of where Jacques Audiard‘s A Prophet will lead you. It feels epic at its monster 149-minute run-time but honestly doesn’t waste a minute of screen time. This is two-and-a-half very tense hours that will fly right by. One of the best films of 2009 and highly recommended on Blu-ray!
ALSO AVAILABLE ON BLU-RAY THIS WEEK
Clicking an image will take you to Amazon.com where you can learn more about and purchase the Blu-ray disc:
I’m not sure how I missed this one last month. A trailer for Henry Selick‘s (Coraline) stop-motion animated James and Giant Peach has turned up on YouTube! Disney has yet to announce the title so all that’s known about the release is what you can see in the trailer. However, it seems as if the Blu-ray disc is being marketed to take advantage of the upcoming Tim Burton film, Alice in Wonderland (Burton was a producer on Peach). It seems likely that we’ll see James and the Giant Peach on Blu-ray in a release that coincides with Wonderland, sometime in June.
Now, this is exactly the Blu-ray news that’ll get me out of bed early on a Thursday morning. Henry Selick‘s brilliant stop-motion adaptation of Neil Gaiman‘s Coraline is making it’s way to Blu-ray, with both 2-D and 3-D formats available on the same disc! This is fantastic! Coraline is the first film I ever had the pleasure to see in 3-D in the theatre and I have to say, I was so taken aback by the effect that I barely noticed the film itself for the first 15-20 minutes or so. After the technical be-dazzlement wore thin, I sat stunned, wholly taken in by the content alone. This was not only a fantastic film but an incredible theatrical experience for me. One I can’t wait to replicate in my home theatre.
(WARNING: SCIENCE ZONE AHEAD) But while details of the process used to bring 3-D to the Coraline Blu-ray are nowhere to be found at this early date we can safely assume that the four included pair of glasses will be of the old-school anaglyph (red/blue) variety as opposed to the more effective polarized lenses used in theaters. To bring this experience home, I would need to own a projector that will show the film at 72fps, a push-pull electro-optical modulator called a ZScreen in front of the lens, switching polarization and a special cinema screen to minimize depolarization and to reflect back as much light as possible to counter polarization losses. Sigh. With all the gadgets involved and the ridiculous expense attached I don’t see high quality 3-D happening in living rooms anytime soon for those of us not named Bill Gates. Until the time when a new technology succeeds and becomes an affordable solution for the home, we’ll have to settle for the same cheap alternative used on The Creature from the Black Lagoon over half a century ago. (NOTE: END OF SCIENCE ZONE)
With or without 3-D, the film is a triumph of animation and of story. And the Blu-ray disc looks set to please as well:
CORALINE
(July 21, 2009, MSRP $39.98)
2-D and 3-D Versions Included
4 Pairs of 3-D Glasses Included
Video: 1.85:1 1080p VC-1
Audio: 5.1 DTS-HD Master Audio
Special Features Include:
• Feature commentary with director Henry Selick and composer Bruno Coulais (on 2-D and 3-D versions)
• Deleted scenes
• The Making of ‘Coraline’
• Voicing the Characters
• Creepy Coraline
• D-Box
• U-Control (on 2-D version only):
• BD Live:
• Digital copy of 2-D version (expires July 31, 2010)
Link to details of Coraline Collector’s Edition DVD: www.nbcuniversalstore.com
To learn more about Coraline visit this excellent blog: EVIL BUTTONS
Review at FPS Magazine: Coraline Review