THE SERIES:
REVIEW:
Wow. What can I say about this season of Game of Thrones that hasn’t been exclaimed a thousand times over across the internet? Stunning. Fearless. Red!
I understand the stories that make up every episode and season of this award-winning show are merely adaptations of a popular series of fantasy books and should therefore not have too much praise heaped upon them for remarkable character arcs and groundbreaking plot work but holy good god, never before has anything the likes of Game of Thrones been attempted on the small or, for that matter, large screen. The scripts are tight but give most every character room to breathe and grow, all the while never feeling to the audience as if much time is allowed to pass, each scene bounding breathlessly to the next. It’s a remarkable feat of script craft, to be certain, to achieve this level of narrative depth juxtaposed with so much incredible, high-fantasy action and intrigue in so little screen time. I’m in awe.
Make on this season and those before might sound akin to hyperbole but Game of Thrones has proven itself, thus far, to be absolutely critic-proof (aside from those staunch hold-outs who insist on comparing the show to the book.) One can pick nits, sure, but on the whole, this is the best the medium has ever been. I only thank the good lords and ladies of HBO that there’ll be more!
In terms of the audio/visual presentation of the series on Blu-ray, well, I’m sure if you’re an avid reader of this site you know what to expect. Game of Thrones is, once again, the height of technical perfection on Blu. It looks far more detailed, colourful and vibrant than even the very attractive 1080p broadcast version of the show you no doubt viewed via cable or satellite last year. Audio is perfectly immersive and dynamic in another series of spot-on DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 tracks. These are very near reference quality discs.
Special features are once again plentiful (you’ll find a complete list below the screencaps), with the number of informative and fun commentary tracks outnumbering the actual episodes. In addition to the usual plethora of featurettes, deleted scenes and in-episode guides, this 5-Blu-ray set also includes a pretty rad picture-in-picture type of in-episode experience, not unlike Warner’s much-loved Maximum Movie Mode. There are a ton of interviews and behind-the-scenes videos to be screened within The Rains of Castamere Unveiled feature, as well as in-experience clickables. There’s no shortage of material to delve into here. Enough to please even the most passionate GoT fan.
Highest possible recommendation!!
SCREENSHOTS:
Click to enlarge
(Note: All screenshots are created in the lossy jpg format which may cause additional compression artifacts and noise in the image.)
SPECIAL FEATURES:
THE FILM:
REVIEW:
There’s a lot to like in this incarnation of Justice League but I don’t think it’s for me. Justice League: War is aptly named as most of its brief 79-minute runtime is taken up with battle scenes. Which is great in a comic book action adventure animated feature, don’t get me wrong. But the characters really suffer. There’s only so much you can do in such a short time with such a grand cast. And Justice League: War, for my money doesn’t quite succeed.
But the animation is bananas, with strong character designs by Phil Bourassa (Young Justice) and a powerful score by Kevin Kliesch. The voice acting, as usual, is top notch.
Justice League: War is a typical DC animation Blu-ray release with an encode that’s most likely faithful to a source that exhibits “flaws” like the occasional moment of colour banding or aliasing. It looks great for what it is – bright and colourful and very modern – and only suffers at the hands of the lower budget of the feature animation itself. The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track is suitably aggressive and dynamic. Excellent.
I enjoyed the special features on the Justice League: War Blu-ray but they’re not perfect. In lieu of a full commentary track, Jim Lee, illustrator of the original comics from which the film has been adapted, and director Jay Oliva sit down for a 20-minute long video examination of key scenes. They cover enough material that it feels like a nearly complete commentary track. Lee is also featured in a half-hour long biography doc which is only really relevant to the comic book crowd. The 24-minute long “Act D: From Animatic to Pencil Test” is often technical and offers a deeper look inside the creation of the film. There’s also a 9-minute long preview of the next DC animation project, Son of Batman, and four SD episodes of older DC Universe animated shows.
SCREENSHOTS:
Click to enlarge
(Note: All screenshots are created in the lossy jpg format which may cause additional compression artifacts and noise in the image.)
SPECIAL FEATURES:
THE FILM:
REVIEW:
I love the films of Pedro Almodóvar but his latest, I’m So Excited is a disappointment. The whole thing feels like a deranged fantasy, with none of the characters stuck on the “imperiled” airplane ever reacting with a level of panic that feels genuine. It doesn’t help the drama that many of the critical puzzle pieces of the plot are rooted on the ground, miles away from the drama in the clouds. I understand, though, that the film is meant to be a farce and, with that in mind, the treatment of the characters is not at all inappropriate. But the pacing and the tone don’t support the feeling of a farcical take on potential disaster. It’s a mix of styles and execution that just falls flat.
That said, this is Almodóvar. And Almodóvar at his worst is better than the majority of Hollywood pap. I’m So Excited has plenty of laughs and is, overall, quite fun, despite not coming together as well as the writer/director’s previous films.
I’m So Excited is striking on Blu-ray, brimming with colour and detail in every frame. The film was shot digitally on Arri Alexa Studio cams and every bit looks pristine here. Simply gorgeous. The Spanish language DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track is also fantastic, providing a dynamic representation of all sonic aspects of the film from the dialogue and the sound effects to the bombastic musical numbers.
Bonus features are sadly few and far between. The “Making of” doc clocks in at an anaemic 6-minutes in length, feeling more like a clip show. The most interesting and substantial bonus is “Presenting I’m So Excited!“, a half-hour long sit-down with Almodóvar and actors Carlos Areces, Blanca Suárez, and Miguel Ángel Silvestre.
SCREENSHOTS:
Click to enlarge
(Note: All screenshots are created in the lossy jpg format which may cause additional compression artifacts and noise in the image.)
SPECIAL FEATURES:
THE FILM:
REVIEW:
Grey Gardens isn’t the kind of documentary that’ll play well to a wide audience these days but nearly four decades since its initial release it provides a glimpse into a couple of lives so outside of societal norms that it might have well been filmed yesterday. It’s a fascinating look into anther world.
Fans of the film might wonder how much better the 16mm footage will look on Criterion’s new Blu-ray upgrade when compared to their 2001 DVD release. The answer is SO much better! This 1080p upgrade allows the transfer to actually look like you’re watching film. The film grain comes on like a heavy curtain at times but that’s a good thing in this case. It’s evidence that the transfer is true to the source. Colours are robust and vivid and contrast is spot on. This disc is a joy to look at. The lossless audio upgrade is also substantial, providing additional depth and clarity not heard on the compressed DVD track.
There are also upgrades in the extras department of the disc. In addition to porting over the commentary, interviews, trailers and photos from the 2001 DVD, Criterion has added some exceptional new bonus goodies – an intro to the film by director Albert Maysles (recorded in 2006) and a whole new feature film, The Beales of Grey Gardens, composed from the outtakes of the original 1975 shoot! If the incredible new high-def transfer didn’t give you reason enough to upgrade, surely the bump in extras will.
Highly recommended!
SCREENSHOTS:
Click to enlarge
(Note: All screenshots are created in the lossy jpg format which may cause additional compression artifacts and noise in the image.)
SPECIAL FEATURES:
THE FILMS:
REVIEW:
The simple fact that something like the World Cinema Project disc set exists totally blows me away. Six relatively obscure but important films from six different countries spanning nearly fifty years, all restored, preserved and collected in a small box you can keep in your home. Astounding. This is a hardcore cinephile’s dream come true.
As you’d expect, the presentation of the six films is a mixed bag, the older films generally showing the strains of their age moreso than their younger siblings. Redes (1936) is in the worst shape, having been restored from surviving elements a few generations off the originals. Given the films history it’s amazing we’re able to watch it at all. The only other problematic film in the bunch is The Housemaid (1960) which had two previously missing reels digitally reconstructed and restored from an English-subtitled print found in 1990. Evidence of digital manipulation is present here but, again, given the fact that those two reels had to have subs painted out, frame by frame, and then matched as closely as possible to the original negative scans comprising the rest of the restoration, this presentation is a miracle. The other four films look wonderful, across the board, exhibiting impressive detail and contrast. Audio is presented in lossless mono on all six films with audio generally matching up to the quality of the video – Redes and The Housemaid are far from pristine, while the other four films sound anywhere from good to great.
Extras are uniform across the board, with each film receiving a short introduction by Martin Scorsese (generally 2-3 minutes in length) as well as a follow up piece in the form of interviews, short docs and visual essays (ranging from 8-19 minutes in length). The packaging is unnecessarily thick, despite the six films being spread across only three Blu-ray discs (two films a disc) and as a result of the inclusion of the DVD versions in the box. I’m conceptually into the idea of the new dual format releases but in cases like the Martin Scorsese’s World Cinema Project box, it seems to cause the release to take up substantially more shelf space than would be otherwise necessary.
Highly recommended!
SCREENSHOTS:
Click to enlarge
(Note: All screenshots are created in the lossy jpg format which may cause additional compression artifacts and noise in the image.)
TOUKI BOUKI
REDES
A RIVER CALLED TITAS
DRY SUMMER
TRANCES
THE HOUSEMAID
SPECIAL FEATURES:
THE FILM:
This is one of the most important Blu-ray releases of 2013. Ozu is one of the finest filmmakers of the last century and Tokyo Story is commonly accepted to be his best work so it pleases me to say that this disc does the master and his film proud. Fans who’ve been anxiously awaiting this upgrade from Criterion’s 2003 DVD release won’t be disappointed with the new “Dual Format” package. Not only does it look and sound miles beyond the old disc but it’s stacked with extras.
The package contains a single Blu-ray, with two DVDs including the same content but in standard def, spanning the discs. I watched the Blu-ray and was blown away by the improvement from not only my old Criterion DVD but also the BFI Region B Blu-ray from a few years back. Criterion’s new release looks like it’s been afforded further restoration, cleaning up a lot of the dirt and damage apparent on the old transfers. Contrast is also improved, drawing further detail from the print.
My only gripe about the entire affair is that a film as substantial as this was crammed onto one disc with literally hours of additional high-def content. I wish the Tokyo Story package contained two Blu-ray discs – one for the film alone, encoded at a super high bitrate, and one for the extras (several documentary films – see below) – and skipped the DVDs entirely. I think a higher bitrate encode would’ve really allowed the transfer to sing. As it is, it’s close to being a revelation, but with a little more room to breathe I have a feeling this would be a perfect release.
The lossless mono audio track is surprisingly robust and stable for a film of this age. Restoration work has clearly been afforded to this aspect of the transfer as well, to great benefit. Tokyo Story sounds better than ever!
As I mentioned above, there’s a ridiculous wealth of bonus features on the disc. In terms of content, there’s nothing more I’d ask for – the docs are fantastic and exhaustive and the commentary ported over from the 2003 DVD, informative. But, as previously stated, I wish the three documentaries about Ozu had been given their own disc. Talking with Ozu (40-minutes), I Lived, But… (123-minutes) and Chishu Ryu and Shochiku’s Ofuna Studio (46-minutes) collectively weigh in at nearly four hours in length. That’s a lot of high-def video to cram on one Blu-ray alongside a 136-minute feature film.
Despite my singular reservation about the Tokyo Story presentation, Criterion’s latest release is highly recommended.
REVIEW:
SCREENSHOTS:
Click to enlarge
(Note: All screenshots are created in the lossy jpg format which may cause additional compression artifacts and noise in the image.)
SPECIAL FEATURES:
THE FILMS:
REVIEW:
If you’ve been reading this blog at all over the last five years (holy crap, we’ve been around for five years now!!) you’re probably painfully aware of my love for classic horror films. I’m usually spouting off about Universal and Hammer horror but Roger Corman‘s Poe films are also favourites. With that in mind you won’t be surprised to read that the new Vincent Price Collection Blu-ray set, comprised largely of films Price made with Corman for American International pictures, is my favourite Blu-ray release of 2013. It’s not complete – it’s missing a few critical Price/Corman collabs, as well as the sequel to Phibes – but it’s the best collection of Price flicks I’ve ever seen on home video.
But enough of my nerd-gushing over the films themselves, what you want to know is if the Blu-ray discs look and sound great. You bet your life they do! This isn’t super-high bitrate, fully restored perfection here, but man, these films look amazing. The older the film, the softer the image, generally speaking. But Shout! has done them all proud. None have the benefit of being fully restored – you’ll see flecks and scratches here and there in the brighter scenes – but all the transfers appear honest and film-like, with little digital manipulation present. Colour and detail are great across the board. Audio on all six films is presented in outstanding mono DTS-HD Master Audio tracks, each exhibiting surprising depth and clarity.
This set of six films would be something to sing about if it contained the films alone. But when you consider the ridiculous wealth of bonus features included here, it puts the package firmly in the must-buy category. The commentary tracks, short docs and interviews are all worth checking out but the real joy are the rarely seen Vincent Price intros and outros on most of the films. They were created for Iowa public TV back in 1982 for a series called Vincent Price’s Gothic Horrors and are a true find. I hope Shout! are able to get a hold of the rights to release more Price films in this series in the very near future. I’m fantasizing about getting my grubby paws on a new Price box set every year.
Highly recommended!
SCREENSHOTS:
Click to enlarge
(Note: All screenshots are created in the lossy jpg format which may cause additional compression artifacts and noise in the image.)
FALL OF THE HOUSE OF USHER
THE HAUNTED PALACE
THE MASQUE OF THE RED DEATH
THE PIT AND THE PENDULUM
WITCHFINDER GENERAL
THE ABOMINABLE DR. PHIBES
SPECIAL FEATURES:
THE HAUNTED PALACE
THE MASQUE OF THE RED DEATH
THE PIT AND THE PENDULUM
WITCHFINDER GENERAL
THE ABOMINABLE DR. PHIBES
THE FILMS:
REVIEW:
You should have one of two questions for me regarding the John Cassavetes: Five Films Blu-ray set – should I buy it or should I upgrade from my old DVDs. The answer is yes, either way.
If you’ve never seen any of Cassavetes’ work, know that this box contains five of his most essential films. It’s by no means a complete collection (criminally lacking Husbands and Love Streams, amongst others) but provides the films that are key to understanding his work as a writer/director and his place in film history.
All five films feature brand new high-def transfers that look spectacular and are, across the board, astonishingly film-like. Owners of Criterion’s previously released DVD set will note the substantial upgrade by checking out the screengrabs below. Those expecting a glossy Hollywood image from any of these discs need not apply. Shadows and Faces, in particular, were shot on 16mm and exhibit a grain structure that’s bound to do the average viewer’s head in, if they don’t understand what they’re looking at. For enthusiasts like us, however, every single one of these transfers is pure magic. Each film sports a new lossless audio track, all of which seem more crisp and dynamic than their DVD counterparts, exhibiting a depth the lossy format clearly wasn’t capable of capturing.
If the hours of interviews, commentary tracks and documentaries aren’t enough for those of you seeking the film-school-in-a-box experience, there’s a stellar 80-page book included to keep you up late at night, busy with your studies.
Criterion’s John Cassavetes: Five Films is one of the must-buy Blu-ray releases of the year. Highest possible recommendation!
SCREENSHOTS:
Click to enlarge
(Note: All screenshots are created in the lossy jpg format which may cause additional compression artifacts and noise in the image.)
SHADOWS
FACES
A WOMAN UNDER THE INFLUENCE
THE KILLING OF A CHINESE BOOKIE
OPENING NIGHT
SPECIAL FEATURES:
THE FILM:
REVIEW:
If you can manage to trudge through the early minutes of this 1976 film starring Roger Moore, Ian Holm and a typically but lovably inebriated Lee Marvin, you’re in for a rousing adventure yarn in the spirit of The Man Who Would Be King.
Based somewhat loosely on actual events, Peter Hunt’s (On Her Majesty’s Secret Service) Shout at the Devil spends a lot of its time early on waffling about, putting the characters through their paces before finally, after a convoluted series of plot point, getting to the exciting stuff. There’s a lot to love here and fans of the genre and of the actors will be more than pleased to spend a little extra time with the film.
The Blu-ray looks fantastic for a nearly 40-year-old buried treasure. This has either been slightly restored or the elements used to create this transfer are in fantastic shape. Colours are bold (perhaps pushed a little too much to the warm side of the spectrum) and detail is sharp. The DTS-HD Master Audio track is presented 2.0 but is essentially mono. Again, for a film this age it sounds great, with Maurice Jarre‘s score lighting up the dynamic range whenever it engages.
Sadly, there’s not much to speak of in the way of supplemental material here. Just a photo gallery. Oh, and the Blu-ray also comes packaged with the DVD version.
SPECIAL FEATURES:
THE FILM:
STROMBOLI
EUROPE ’51
JOURNEY TO ITALY
REVIEW:
This box set is going to be on every “Best Of 2013” home video list this year, mark my words. While not technically “complete” (there’s apparently one cut of Stromboli and two of Europe ’51 not included) this is more than film fans could ever hope for when it comes to this trio of rarely seen cinematic gems.
Rossellini and Bergman make a perfect pair. I can’t speak to what they were like together in real life, of course, but on screen, the combination of his language and her performance is pure poetry. I can see how they ended up in a relationship. Rossellini’s storytelling is impeccable and his incisive representations of love and relationships realistic and grounded. And that material is a blessing to an actor like Bergman, who simply lights up the screen in these films, particularly in her incredible transformation through Europe ’51, a film that’s something of a reworking of Rossellini’s own The Flowers of St. Francis. All three films in this set are progressive and modern. Don’t let the fact that they were made 60-years ago dissuade you from watching.
Where the films are nothing alike, however, is in their Blu-ray presentations. And that’s rather understandable given their age and the likely uneven care the source material has been afforded over the years. Journey to Italy looks the best of the three films. Remarkable even, boasting extraordinary depth and contrast. The Italian-language Europa ’51 is probably in the worst shape, with its English-language counterpart Europe ’51 close behind. Both show signs of damage, the Italian version looking softer and less stable. Stromboli and the Italian-language Stromboli terra di Dio, the oldest of the three films, both offer pleasing transfers, with Stromboli terra di Dio looking slightly brighter. All films look very film-like with nary a hint of untoward digital manipulation.
Audio is lossless mono on every film, whether Italian or English language. Journey to Italy offers the greatest dynamic range and has clearly required the least amount of stabilization. The other films show signs of repair but sound across the board quite impressive, considering their age and circumstance.
All right, let’s talk about bonus goodies. This set features nearly seven hours of bonus material. Eight and a half, if you count the commentary track on Journey to Italy. Wow. I’m at a loss for words. I just want to thank Criterion, on behalf of every film fan out there, for going to such incredible lengths to gather and create this stunning collection of supplementary material. They don’t need to do it, you know. They could just release the three films and call it a day. But to go so far as to get the rights to such film treasures as the feature-length archival documentaries Rossellini Through His Own Eyes and Ingrid Bergman Remembered, the old family home movies from Rossellini’s niece, G. Fiorella Mariani, included in the interview with her and Guy Maddin‘s My Dad is 100 Years Old, a short film tribute to Rossellini starring his daughter Isabella Rossellini just goes so far beyond the call of duty, these guys deserve some kind of reward. I guess that reward will just come by way of my eternal allegiance to them and the seemingly unending access I give them to my wallet.
Most of the extras in the set are found on the Journey to Italy disc and on the fourth disc included in the set, dedicated to bonus stuff. The box also includes an 86-page illustrated booklet of essays, letters between Rossellini and Bergman, interviews, articles and more.
I can’t recommend this box set highly enough. If you love film, you need to own this, plain and simple.
SPECIAL FEATURES:
STROMBOLI Special Features:
EUROPA ’51 Special Features:
JOURNEY TO ITALY Special Features: